Example workflow for processing of raw spectral cytometry files
2020-04-28
1 Introduction
In this document, I aim at showing a typical analysis of a spectral cytometry file, including the construction of the spectral decomposition matrix, the actual decomposition, correction of the resulting file (as there generally are minor differences between the single-stained controls and the fully stained sample) and finally converting the resulting flowFrame or flowSet to a dataframe that can be used for any downstream application. Note: This whole package is very much dependent on flowCore, and much of the functionality herein works as an extention of the basic flowCore functionality.
2 Installation
This is how to install the package, if that has not already been done:
if(!requireNamespace("BiocManager", quietly = TRUE))
install.packages("BiocManager")
BiocManager::install("flowSpecs")3 Example data description
The dataset that is used in this vinjette, and that is the example dataset in the package generally, is a PBMC sample stained with 12 fluorochrome-conjugated antibodies against a wide range of leukocyte antigens. Included is also a set of single-stained controls, that fill the same function with spectral cytometry as in conventional ditto. The files were generated on a 44 channel Cytek Aurora® instrument 2018-10-25.
library(flowSpecs)
library(flowCore)
data("unmixCtrls")
unmixCtrls## A flowSet with 15 experiments.
##
## column names:
## Time SSC-H SSC-A V1-A V2-A V3-A V4-A V5-A V6-A V7-A V8-A V9-A V10-A V11-A V12-A V13-A V14-A V15-A V16-A FSC-H FSC-A B1-A B2-A B3-A B4-A B5-A B6-A B7-A B8-A B9-A B10-A B11-A B12-A B13-A B14-A B15-A B16-A R1-A R2-A R3-A R4-A R5-A R6-A R7-A R8-A R9-A R10-Adata('fullPanel')
fullPanel[,seq(4,7)]## flowFrame object 'fullPanel.fcs'
## with 8000 cells and 4 observables:
## name desc range minRange maxRange
## $P4 V1-A <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## $P5 V2-A <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## $P6 V3-A <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## $P7 V4-A <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## 416 keywords are stored in the 'description' slotAs can be noted, flowSpecs adheres to flowCore standards, and thus uses flowFrames and flowSets as input to all user functions.
4 Construction of spectral unmixing matrix
To do this, we need the single-stained unmixing controls. As the fluorescent sources can be of different kinds, such as from antibodies, fluorescent proteins, or dead cell markers, the specMatCalc function accepts any number of different such groups. However, the groups need to have a common part of their names. If this was not the case during acquisition, the names of the fcs files can always be changed afterwards. To check the names, run the sampleNames function from flowCore:
sampleNames(unmixCtrls)## [1] "Beads_AF647_IgM.fcs" "Beads_AF700_CD4.fcs" "Beads_APCCy7_CD19.fcs"
## [4] "Beads_BV605_CD14.fcs" "Beads_BV650_CD56.fcs" "Beads_BV711_CD11c.fcs"
## [7] "Beads_BV785_CD8a.fcs" "Beads_FITC_CD41b.fcs" "Beads_PB_CD3.fcs"
## [10] "Beads_PE_X.fcs" "Beads_PECy7_CD45RA.fcs" "Beads_unstained.fcs"
## [13] "Dead_PO_DCM.fcs" "Dead_unstained.fcs" "PBMC_unstained.fcs"This shows that we have three groups of samples: “Beads”, “Dead” and “PBMC”. The two first are groups that define the fluorochromes from antibodies and the dead cell marker (which is pacific orange-NHS in this case). The last one, “PBMC”, will be used for autofluorescence correction. For obvious reasons, the autofluo control should always be from the same type of sample as the samples that will be analyzed downstream. With this knowledge about the groups of samples, we can now create the matrix:
specMat <- specMatCalc(unmixCtrls, groupNames = c("Beads_", "Dead_"),
autoFluoName = "PBMC_unstained.fcs")
str(specMat)## num [1:13, 1:42] 0.000058 0.001032 0.000649 0.029998 0.052618 ...
## - attr(*, "dimnames")=List of 2
## ..$ : chr [1:13] "AF647_IgM" "AF700_CD4" "APCCy7_CD19" "BV605_CD14" ...
## ..$ : chr [1:42] "V1-A" "V2-A" "V3-A" "V4-A" ...Here we can see that a matrix with the original fluorescence detector names as column names, and the new fluorochrome/marker names as row names has been created. The function does a lot of preprocessing, with automatic gating of the most dominant population, etc, to ensure the best possible resolution and consistency in the determination of the matrix.
5 Spectral unmixing
Now it is time to apply the newly constructed specMat to the fully stained sample. This is done in the following way:
fullPanelUnmix <- specUnmix(fullPanel, specMat)
fullPanelUnmix## flowFrame object 'fullPanel.fcs'
## with 8000 cells and 18 observables:
## name desc range minRange maxRange
## $P1 Time <NA> 16777216 0 16777215
## $P2 SSC-H <NA> 4194304 0 4194303
## $P3 SSC-A <NA> 4194304 0 4194303
## $P4 FSC-H <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## $P5 FSC-A <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## $P6 AF647_IgM <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## $P7 AF700_CD4 <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## $P8 APCCy7_CD19 <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## $P9 BV605_CD14 <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## $P10 BV650_CD56 <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## $P11 BV711_CD11c <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## $P12 BV785_CD8a <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## $P13 FITC_CD41b <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## $P14 PB_CD3 <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## $P15 PE_X <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## $P16 PECy7_CD45RA <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## $P17 PO_DCM <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## $P18 Autofluo <NA> 4194304 -111 4194303
## 416 keywords are stored in the 'description' slotNotable is that the names now have been exchanged for the fluorescent molecules instead of the detector channels. The algorithm below this function is currently least squares regression.
6 Transformation
As with all cytometry data, for correct interpretation, the data needs to be transformed using one of the lin-log functions. As the arcsinh function is widely used and also has a single co-function that controls the level of compression aroud zero, it is used in this package. The function has a number of built-in features, such as automatic detection of if the file comes from mass or flow cytometry, and will give differenc cofactors accordingly. It is however always the best practice to set the cofactors individually, to ensure that no artifactual populations are created, which can happen, if there is too much resolution around zero. One automated strategy for this, which would make the arcTrans function unnecessary, is to use the flowVS package.
The arcTrans function requires the names of the variables that should be transformed to be specified.
fullPanelTrans <- arcTrans(fullPanelUnmix, transNames =
colnames(fullPanelUnmix)[6:18])
par(mfrow=c(1,2))
hist(exprs(fullPanelUnmix)[,7], main = "Pre transformation",
xlab = "AF700_CD4", breaks = 200)
hist(exprs(fullPanelTrans)[,7], main = "Post transformation",
xlab = "AF700_CD4", breaks = 200)
As can be seen in the histograms, the ranges, scales and resolution have now
changed dramatically.
(Biologically, the three peaks correspond to CD4- cells, CD4+myeloid cells and
CD4+T-cells, respectively).
7 Investigation of possible unmixing artifacts
An important step in the early processing of cytometry files is to investigate if, or rather where, unmixing artifacts have arisen. There are multiple reasons for the occurrence of such artifacts, but listing them are outside of the scope of this vinjette. In the package, there is one function that is well suited for for this task, and that is the oneVsAllPlot function. When used without specifying a marker, the function will create a folder and save all possible combinations of markers to that folder. Looking at them gives a good overview of the data. In this case, for the vinjette purpose, I am only plotting one of the multi-graphs.
oneVsAllPlot(fullPanelTrans, "AF647_IgM", saveResult = FALSE)
This shows a typical artifact between BV650_CD56 and AF647_IgM: it is biologically extremely unlikely that the higher expression one sees of CD56, the more extremely below zero do the values become for IgM_AF647.
8 Correction of artifacts
Now to one of the more controversial subjects of cytometry, that rightly causes alarm amongst anyone concerned about reproducibility: the correction of artifacts. When this is done aided by fluorescence-minus-one controls (and an automated function with that purpose is being considered for this package), it is less controversial, but even without them, one can follow a few rules, to increase the usefulness of the data. It is namely important to note, that if artifacts, of the kind we will now start to correct, are left in the data, then they are likely to cause incorrect interpretation of the results: As a rule of thumb, one can assume negative correlations for single-positive markers (i.e. positive for x but negative for y) to always be artifacts, as true populations below a negative population cannot exist. Strong positive correlations are unlikely, but occur in biology, so caution and biological considerations should be taken before any corrections of such are attempted, but they should nonetheless be considered, as leaving them in can cause harm.
Normally, when correcting flow cytometry results, one just changes the compensation matrix. In this case, however, where the compensation matrix is not symmetrical, that becomes a non-trivial affair. For that reason, this package introduces a correction matrix, which is a secondary, symmetric matrix only meant to be used on already unmixed files. It can for that reason take both positive and negative values.
When starting the correction phase, we have to create an empty correction matrix.
corrMat <- corrMatCreate(specMat)This is how this correction matrix is meant to be used: A value of 1 corresponds to +100% correction, a value of 0, to 0% correction. Thus: if the value 1 is added to the coordinate [x,y], then if event 1 has a value of 50 in marker x, then event 1 will get +50 in marker y.
Practically, in our case, we see that it seems like BV650_CD56 is slightly “overunmixed” from AF647_IgM. This means that we should add a negative correction. Let us start with 0.1, or 10%.
corrMat["BV650_CD56", "AF647_IgM"] <- -0.1
fullPanelCorr <- correctUnmix(fullPanelUnmix, corrMat)
oneVsAllPlot(fullPanelCorr, "AF647_IgM", saveResult = FALSE)
Here, a few things can be noted. First, the correction function takes the non-
transformed file as input. Second, there is an automatic transformation within
this function, as it would be tedious, always having to rerun the arcTrans
function during this phase, that is generally quite repetitive.
Thrdly, we overdid it, as the population is now clearly “undermixed” instead,
with a considerable bleed-over of CD56+ cells into the IgM marker channel.
Thus, we repeat it with a lower value.
corrMat["BV650_CD56", "AF647_IgM"] <- -0.03
fullPanelCorr <- correctUnmix(fullPanelUnmix, corrMat)
oneVsAllPlot(fullPanelCorr, "AF647_IgM", saveResult = FALSE)
This time, the result was satisfactory. There are other minor defects in the
unmixing, however, such as between AF647_IgM and PE_X. This is typically the
case, and as long as this needs to be done manually, it will use considerable
time, especialy for more complex panels.
Notable is also that as we are just changing the correction matrix, and
redoing the analysis from the unmixed file every time, we do not need to take
the previous values into consideration.
9 Connecting to other non-flowCore compliant applications
Many clustering algorithms and similar take a matrix-like input. If data is to be combined from multiple fcs files, and clustered together, the most convenient way might be to create a long data frame containing identifiers as separate columns from the flowSet. The flowSpecs package contains a function to do this. It works also for single flowFrames, but there it might be easier to just extract the data with the exprs() function from flowCore.
To set up our file for the task, we will convert it to a flowSet and change its currently non-existent name to something useful.
fullPanelFs <- flowSet(fullPanelTrans)
sampleNames(fullPanelFs) <- "PBMC_full_panel_d1.fcs"The function we are goning to use can chop up the name of the file into multiple strings, if the right information is added in a gsub-compliant format. These strings are then added as new columns to the resulting dataframe, and if the fcs files have been systematically named (or their sampleNames changed to something systematic in accordance with the example above), we will in this way be able to group the data based on the new categorizing columns.
fullPanelDf <- flowSet2LongDf(fullPanelFs, idInfo =
list("Tissue" = "|_full_panel_..\\.fcs",
"Donor" = "...._full_panel_|\\.fcs"))
str(fullPanelDf)## 'data.frame': 8000 obs. of 21 variables:
## $ Time : num 257175 537280 559170 339827 139500 ...
## $ SSC.H : num 351531 902606 615990 502753 1235630 ...
## $ SSC.A : num 432574 1127647 784518 604359 1734489 ...
## $ FSC.H : num 1629492 1978410 1634036 1716769 2040715 ...
## $ FSC.A : num 1912225 2364255 1855925 1925570 2920881 ...
## $ AF647_IgM : num 1.73 1.55 1.92 1.96 2.66 ...
## $ AF700_CD4 : num 5.058 -0.333 5.279 4.866 2.667 ...
## $ APCCy7_CD19 : num -2.812 0.373 -1.794 -0.794 1.32 ...
## $ BV605_CD14 : num -1.066 5.901 0.267 0.921 5.966 ...
## $ BV650_CD56 : num 1.288 2.973 0.266 -0.328 2.816 ...
## $ BV711_CD11c : num 1.01 2.94 1.13 0.52 4.26 ...
## $ BV785_CD8a : num 2.17 1.2 2 2.5 1.36 ...
## $ FITC_CD41b : num 0.952 1.287 1.032 0.327 1.935 ...
## $ PB_CD3 : num 5.031 -0.802 4.039 4.198 0.144 ...
## $ PE_X : num -0.938 0.821 0.6 -0.295 1.145 ...
## $ PECy7_CD45RA: num 6.646 3.109 3 0.232 3.851 ...
## $ PO_DCM : num 2.112 2.391 2.41 0.359 2.948 ...
## $ Autofluo : num 2.62 3.25 2.46 2.04 3.64 ...
## $ Tissue : chr "PBMC" "PBMC" "PBMC" "PBMC" ...
## $ Donor : chr "d1" "d1" "d1" "d1" ...
## $ acqDate : chr "25-Oct-2018" "25-Oct-2018" "25-Oct-2018" "25-Oct-2018" ...This dataframe can now be used in other applications.
10 Summary
In this vinjette, a typical spectral cytometry analysis is performed, which is currently the main objective with the package. However, a number of functions for automatic gating, CyTOF fcs file cleanup, etc are in the pipe line and will be added to the package in the coming months, together with new vinjettes.
11 Session information
sessionInfo()## R version 4.0.0 (2020-04-24)
## Platform: x86_64-w64-mingw32/x64 (64-bit)
## Running under: Windows Server 2012 R2 x64 (build 9600)
##
## Matrix products: default
##
## locale:
## [1] LC_COLLATE=C
## [2] LC_CTYPE=English_United States.1252
## [3] LC_MONETARY=English_United States.1252
## [4] LC_NUMERIC=C
## [5] LC_TIME=English_United States.1252
##
## attached base packages:
## [1] stats graphics grDevices utils datasets methods base
##
## other attached packages:
## [1] flowSpecs_1.2.0 flowCore_2.0.0 knitr_1.28 BiocStyle_2.16.0
##
## loaded via a namespace (and not attached):
## [1] Rcpp_1.0.4.6 plyr_1.8.6 compiler_4.0.0
## [4] pillar_1.4.3 cytolib_2.0.0 BiocManager_1.30.10
## [7] tools_4.0.0 digest_0.6.25 lattice_0.20-41
## [10] evaluate_0.14 lifecycle_0.2.0 tibble_3.0.1
## [13] gtable_0.3.0 pkgconfig_2.0.3 rlang_0.4.5
## [16] magick_2.3 yaml_2.2.1 parallel_4.0.0
## [19] hexbin_1.28.1 xfun_0.13 dplyr_0.8.5
## [22] stringr_1.4.0 vctrs_0.2.4 tidyselect_1.0.0
## [25] stats4_4.0.0 grid_4.0.0 glue_1.4.0
## [28] Biobase_2.48.0 R6_2.4.1 BiocParallel_1.22.0
## [31] rmarkdown_2.1 bookdown_0.18 farver_2.0.3
## [34] reshape2_1.4.4 purrr_0.3.4 RProtoBufLib_2.0.0
## [37] ggplot2_3.3.0 magrittr_1.5 scales_1.1.0
## [40] matrixStats_0.56.0 htmltools_0.4.0 ellipsis_0.3.0
## [43] BiocGenerics_0.34.0 assertthat_0.2.1 colorspace_1.4-1
## [46] labeling_0.3 stringi_1.4.6 RcppParallel_5.0.0
## [49] munsell_0.5.0 crayon_1.3.4 zoo_1.8-7